Could we resurrect dinosaurs from fossil embryos?

Not All It's Cracked Up to Be

Over the past decade, advances in stem cells, salvaging ancient DNA and rebuilding genomes have brought the concept of "de-extinction" -- particularly of genetic cousins of living species -- closer to realization [sources: Kolata; Zimmer]. Just how close, and what this might mean to much more ancient animals, remains less clear.

Using frozen cells, scientists in 2003 successfully cloned an extinct Pyrenean ibex, aka a bucardo (Capra pyrenaica pyrenaica), but it died minutes later [sources: Kolata; Mabry; Zimmer]. For years, Australian researchers have been trying to return the Southern gastric brooding frog (Rheobatrachus silus), the last of which croaked several decades ago, to the lily pad of the living, but the results have yet to last beyond the early embryonic stage [source: Kolata].

Although stumbling, these first steps raise hopes of more ambitious resurrections to come, including woolly mammoths, passenger pigeons and a Yukon horse extinct for around 70 millennia -- which sounds like a long time, until you realize it's only one-tenth of 1 percent as long ago as the most recent dinosaur extinction [source: Kolata].

Even if dino DNA were no older than yesterday's yogurt, however, numerous ethical and practical concerns should cause all but the maddest scientists to hesitate before sending in the clones. After all, how would we regulate such a process? Who would perform it and when? How would de-extinction affect the Endangered Species Act? What of the pain and suffering experienced by failed attempts? Might we breed dead diseases back into existence, or end up with the equivalent of invasive species on steroids [sources: Kolata; Mabry]?

There are upsides, of course. Much like the reintroduction of wolves to Yellowstone Park, "rolling back" recent extinctions could help restore balance to damaged ecosystems, and some say mankind owes a debt to the animals it has offed [sources: Kolata; Mabry; Zimmer].

For now at least, the DNA issue makes the question academic. It is conceivable that a much more recent creature, such as a frozen woolly mammoth, might produce an intact (if freezer-burned) cell, but as far as dinosaurs are concerned, Lufengosaurus' broken-down proteins might be the closest we ever come to "Jurassic Park" [source: Kolata].

Alternatively, they could try to "back-breed" an ancestral animal into existence by mating descendants with distinctive genes inherited from it. Since 1945, some German breeders have claimed to have accomplished the feat with the aurochs (Bos primigenius), an extinct wild ox and progenitor of modern cattle, but scientists remain dubious [sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica; Kolata].

Author's Note: Could we resurrect dinosaurs from fossil embryos?

For every botanist who fears Cretaceous kudzu, there are two pharmaceutical reps salivating over Mesozoic Minoxidil. Me, I side with the folks who are in it for the wonder, pure and simple -- the wonder born of books, of bags of varicolored plastic reptiles and of Ray Harryhausen films.

Related Articles


  • Barrett, P.M. P. Upchurch and W. Xiao-Lin. "Cranial Osteology of Lufengosaurus Huenei Young (Dinosauria: Prosauropoda) from the Lower Jurassic of Yunnan, People's Republic of China." Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. Vol. 25, no. 4. Page 806. 2005.
  • Bayles, Ken. "The Biological Significance of Bacterial Biofilm." University of Nebraska Medical Center/Nebraska Public Health Laboratory.
  • BBC. "Sauropod Dinosaurs."
  • BBC. "Sauropodomorph Dinosaurs."
  • Crisp, Edward. "Sauropodomorpha: The Prosauropods and the Sauropods." Lecture 1: Geology 397: Special Topics: Introduction to Paleontology.
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Aurochs."
  • Gannon, Megan. "Jurassic Park Won't Happen: Dino DNA Dead." Oct. 10, 2012.
  • Gilbert, Scott F. "Pressure as a Developmental Agent." DevBio, a Companion to Developmental Biology Ninth Edition.
  • Horner, Jack. "Shape-shifting Dinosaurs." TED Talk. November 2011.
  • Kaye, Thomas, Gary Gaugler and Zbigniew Sawlowicz. "Dinosaurian Soft Tissues Interpreted as Bacterial Biofilms." PLoS ONE. Vol. 3, no. 7. Page e2808.
  • Kolata, Gina. "Dolly, the First Cloned Mammal, is Dead." The New York Times. Feb. 14, 2003.
  • Kolata, Gina. "So You're Extinct? Scientists Have Gleam in Eye." The New York Times. March 18, 2013.
  • Mabry, Marcus. "Bringing Back the Dead: The Ethics of Reversing Extinction." The New York Times [VIDEO]. March 19, 2013.
  • Reisz, Robert R., Timothy D. Huang, Eric M. Roberts, Shin Rung Peng, Corwin Sullivan, Koen Stein, Aaron R. H. LeBlanc, Dar Bin Shieh, Rong Seng Chang, Cheng Cheng Chiang, Chuanwei Yang and Shiming Zhong. "Embryology of Early Jurassic Dinosaur from China with Evidence of Preserved Organic Remains." Nature. Vol. 496. Page 210. April 2013.
  • Schweitzer, Mary H., Jennifer L. Wittmeyer and John R. Horner. "Soft Tissue and Cellular Preservation in Vertebrate Skeletal Elements from the Cretaceous to the Present." Proceedings of the Royal Society B. Vol. 274. Page 183. 2007.
  • Schweitzer, Mary H., Jennifer L. Wittmeyer, John R. Horner and Jan K. Toporski. "Soft Tissue Vessels and Cellular Preservation in Tyrannosaurus Rex." Science. Vol. 307. Page 1952. 2005.
  • Than, Ker. "Baby Dinosaurs Flexed Muscles Inside Their Eggs." National Geographic. April 10, 2013.
  • University of Bristol. "Sauropod Eggs." Department of Earth Sciences.
  • World Book. "Lufengosaurus."
  • Zimmer, Carl. "Bringing Them Back to Life." National Geographic. April 2013.

More to Explore