Understand? Your Brain Signals Will Tell

By: Amanda Onion

EEG skullcap
It might be hard to feign understanding if you're wearing this skullcap outfitted with wired electrodes that monitors brain activity and can assess comprehension. University of Rochester photo/courtesy Edmund Lalor

Remember the voice of Charlie Brown's teacher: "Wha wha wha wha ..."? Sometimes we can hear someone speaking, but that doesn't always mean we're tuning in. Now neuroscientists have identified a way of detecting brain signals that indicate when a person is actually understanding speech.

The technique, which applies machine learning, represents an advance in using relatively inexpensive EEG (electroencephalography) technology (think skullcap outfitted with wired electrodes) to monitor electrical brain activity and assess comprehension. The approach could offer a sensitive measure of language development in infants and comprehension among patients, including those in a reduced state of consciousness.


"Speech is really amazing, but we're so used to it and our brains are so good at understanding a steady stream of words that we often take it for granted," says Edmund Lalor, associate professor of biomedical engineering and neuroscience at the University of Rochester and Trinity College Dublin. Lalor, who oversaw the study published March 2018 in the journal Current Biology, points out that words roll off the tongues of most speakers at an impressive clip — about 120 to 200 words per minute. Our brains, when alert, have little problem keeping up and interpreting the sounds as syllables, words, paragraphs and meaning.

To detect how much processing is happening as we interpret speech, Lalor and colleagues, including graduate student and lead author, Michael Broderick, first applied machine learning to audiobook recordings and addresses by former President Barack Obama to evaluate when key moments of comprehension should occur. "The machine learning ended up producing a big long vector of numbers for every word," Lalor says. "A word with high number value carries big meaning and should evoke a stronger EEG response." The machine learning's readout aligned with EEG readings from the brains of people listening to the same recordings, he says. Spikes in electrical charge from the brain corresponded to key moments of understanding.

To further test that the spikes in electrical signals corresponded to what people were hearing, the team took EEG readings in other situations where listening was compromised. In one, background noise made hearing the speaker difficult, and the listener's brain signals showed a weaker response (comprehension was improved when the listener was also able to see a video of the speaker). In another experiment, the listener's attention was muddled by the competing sound of another narrator telling a different story at the same time. "This simulates a real-world environment where you're in a noisy room and you have to focus your attention on one speaker and ignore the voices of everyone else around you," explains Broderick. In that noisy bar-like scenario, the subject's EEG readings also showed decreased comprehension.

Finally, the team played audiobook recordings backward. In those tests, Broderick says, the brain's response "disappeared" because the sounds clearly made no sense to the listeners.

The practice of detecting comprehension using EEGs isn't new. Since the early 1980s, researchers have pinpointed EEG spikes when people hear unexpected words in a series. The so-called N400 response is typically seen about 400 milliseconds after the incongruent word is heard. The problem, says Lalor, is in interpreting the meaning of the N400 signal.

"You give people a sentence like 'the dentist told me to brush my tree,' and it has this weird violation in it and so your brain responds. People are still debating what that response might mean," Lalor says. "What's different about ours is it's built on an assessment of the amount of meaning of each word in context. So it may allow us to better understand different aspects of linguistic processing."

While Lalor admits their model could be refined, he suggests that the EEG tests, which are much cheaper and more accessible than MRIs, could find several useful applications. Parents who may be concerned about their child's development could request them for children even as young as 18 months, when early language comprehension begins. At that stage, EEG readings should signal some basic language comprehension, Lalor says. If they don't, it could be an early sign of a language problem, which might not otherwise be diagnosed until a later age.

The testing also could offer an inexpensive way of evaluating patients in an apparent vegetative state. Lalor says it could be as simple as attaching electrodes to a patient, having them listen to an audiobook for an hour and then running analysis. Damian Cruse, a psychologist at the U.K.'s University of Birmingham who has analyzed brain function among people with compromised consciousness, called the team's method "very promising," adding that approaches like these could "provide families and caregivers with vital information."

Looking to the future, Lalor even envisions developing wearable EEG tests that could take an instant read on whether, say, a soldier in a field of battle, or a pilot in a busy airspace is not only hearing instructions, but — unlike the students in Charlie Brown's classroom — also registering them.

"If the signals are there," he says, "then you know that they're understanding."


HealthAllergy BasicsNothing to Sneeze at: Allergies May Affect the BrainHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemWhat is the extrasensory brain?HealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemCan brain foods make you smarter?HealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemTest Your BrainHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemThe Brain and Mental HealthHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemThe Brain and Nervous System: The Body's Command CenterHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemAre teens’ brains fully developed?HealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemBrain Teasers and Mind GamesHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemScientists Discover Your Brain Makes FructoseHealthBrain & Central Nervous System5 Things You Didn’t Know About Donating Your Brain to ScienceHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemBrain and Central Nervous SystemHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemThe Cerebellum Is the Body's Little BrainHealthBrain & Central Nervous SystemHow 'Savant Syndrome' Makes Some People, and Their Brains, ExtraordinaryHealthDreamsHow does the brain transform reality into dreams?HealthDrugs & AlcoholWeed Enthusiast Arrested for Keeping Human Brain Under His PorchHealthFitness InformationMind Games: Creating New Brain CellsHealthHuman BehaviorIntrovert and Extrovert Brains Aren't the SameHealthInfant HealthFemale Newborns May Fare Better After Some Brain InjuriesHealthNeurological ConditionsQuestions to Ask Brain SpecialistsHealthNeurological ConditionsWhen Wisecracks and Puns Are Symptoms of Brain DamageHealthNeurological ConditionsAgitation and Depression in Patients with Brain DiseaseHealthNeurological ConditionsTotally Tone-deaf? The Problem Is in Your Brain, Not Your EarsHealthModern Medical TreatmentsGroovy News: Shrooms Help Reset Depressed BrainHealthPreventive CareHow to Prevent Brain InfectionsHealthRespiratory ConditionsDoes altitude sickness cause brain swelling?HealthSenior Health & LifestyleDon't Forget -- Give Your Brain a Workout, TooHealthStress ManagementEffect of Stress on the BrainHealthStress ManagementIsolation and Monotony Stress the Brain. Here's How to CopeHealthTeenage HealthCertain Adolescent Brains Can't Stop Gaming. That's Good and Bad — Here's WhyHealthWeight LossIs a Hormone in Our Brains the Key to Burning Fat? HealthWomen's General HealthWomen's Brains Harder Hit by Alcohol
ScienceBiological FieldsHow Does a Slime Mold Make Decisions Without a Brain?ScienceEmotionsIs morality located in the brain?ScienceEmotionsIs emotional intelligence a better indicator of brain health than IQ?ScienceEveryday MythsCan our brains see the fourth dimension?ScienceEvolutionDid Schizophrenia Evolve Along With Our Brains?ScienceThe Human BrainHow Your Brain WorksScienceThe Human BrainHow Brain Death WorksScienceThe Human BrainHow Brain Mapping WorksScienceThe Human BrainAre teenage brains really different from adult brains?ScienceThe Human BrainWhy are people's brains different sizes?ScienceThe Human BrainIs the human brain still evolving?ScienceThe Human BrainIs my brain making me buy things I don't need?ScienceThe Human BrainHow Albert Einstein's Brain WorkedScienceThe Human BrainIs the brain hardwired for religion?ScienceThe Human BrainDoes Your Brain Get Tired Like the Rest of Your Body?ScienceThe Human BrainCan brain damage lead to extraordinary art?ScienceThe Human BrainHow Deep Brain Stimulation WorksScienceThe Human BrainIs the computer a good model for the brain?ScienceThe Human BrainCould a brain scan tell you if you're going to become a criminal?ScienceThe Human BrainAre you really only using 10 percent of your brain?ScienceThe Human BrainDo men and women have different brains?ScienceThe Human BrainNeanderthals Had Bigger Brains Than Modern Humans — Why Are We Smarter?ScienceThe Human BrainThe Human Brain Is Hardwired for PoetryScienceThe Human BrainUnderstand? Your Brain Signals Will TellScienceThe Human BrainYes, Conspiracy Theorists’ Brains Really Are DifferentScienceThe Human BrainCan your brain have a traffic jam?ScienceThe Human BrainRelying on GPS Prevents Parts of Your Brain From ActivatingScienceThe Human Brain'Aleppo Moments': What Causes Our Brains to Freeze Under Pressure?ScienceThe Human BrainThe Human BrainScienceThe Human BrainHow Brainwashing WorksScienceThe Human BrainHow does your brain impact your survival chances in the wilderness?ScienceThe Human BrainBinaural Beats: Does This Auditory Illusion Really Calm Your Brain?ScienceThe Human BrainHow does the brain create an uninterrupted view of the world?