In the world of pain, women hold the ultimate trump card: childbirth. Stereotypically, men might seem better equipped to grin and bear a ghastly range of injuries, but they can never experience what many consider to be the height of human agony that takes place in hospital delivery rooms.
A pregnant woman's body even undergoes certain changes in the third trimester to prepare it for labor pains. Especially during the last 18 days of pregnancy, a soon-to-be-mother's pain threshold elevates as pain-mitigating opioid receptors go on red alert and levels of pain-reducing hormones spike [source: Toomey]. In fact, even after the baby is born, a mother will continue to demonstrate a higher pain tolerance than women who haven't had children, according to a 1992 study from the University of Western Ontario [source: Hapidou and DeCatanzaro].
But while women can endure the excruciating pain of childbirth, studies show that they're more sensitive to general pain than men [source: Society for Neuroscience]. In fact, over a lifetime, women experience more pain than men, and of all cohorts, white women older than 45 years report the most pain [source: Kritz].
To get a sense of how wide this painful gender gap is, consider the prevalence rates of certain chronic conditions:
- Women report 40 percent more osteoporosis pain than men.
- One in five women suffers from migraine headaches, compared to one in 17 men.
- Nine times more women than men are affected by fibromyalgia.
[source: National Institutes of Health]
Of course, sorting out the gender disparities of pain responses doesn't boil down to women being the weaker sex. Rather, male and female bodies don't process pain the same way. If a man and a woman each place their hands on a hot stove, different parts of their brains will activate. In 2003, researchers at UCLA discovered that the cognitive, or analytic, region of the male brain lights up, while the female limbic system, the brain's emotional headquarters, springs into action [source: University of California - Los Angeles].
So does that emotionally charged limbic response mean that women are merely making a louder fuss than men over the same amount of pain? Not quite.
Different Bodies, Different Pain Responses
When it comes to coping with pain, women are the more voluble sex [source: Kritz]. Men, on the other hand, tend to bear their burdens quietly. Some researchers attribute that pattern to social conditioning; gender roles permit girls to cry and express their feelings more openly than boys, who are expected to keep a stiff upper lip.
But a study at the University of Florida debunks this social theory. Psychologists offered male and female participants a certain amount of money depending on how long they were able to hold their hands in an ice water bath. The researchers hypothesized that the monetary reward would eliminate any social gender norms, making both sexes equally motivated to hold their hands in the freezing water for as long as possible [source: Dye]. However, even with the cash incentive, the men still outlasted the women.
Psychologists also theorize that women's innate mindfulness might contribute to heightened pain sensitivity. In general, women are more attuned to how they feel physically, which might mentally predispose them to noticing pain. Females also have a higher incidence rate of anxiety and depression, which researchers have linked to greater pain sensitivity in women -- but not in men [source: Toomey].
Furthermore, research indicates that female bodies naturally respond to painful stimuli more intensely than males'. In one experiment, women's pupils dilated faster than men's when uncomfortable pressure was applied to their fingers. Since pupil dilation is a physiological response to pain that's controlled by the autonomic nervous system, the study demonstrated that the females' keener pain responses are beyond conscious control [source: Toomey]. And to top things off, fluctuating female hormones can either dampen or amplify pain on any given day.
For the women in the ice water study, research indicates that the time of the month could've impacted their pain tolerance. Although scientists haven't been able to quantify the precise effects of the menstrual cycle on pain, studies have drawn a correlation between estrogen and pain thresholds in women. Specifically, when estrogen levels crest, the female body responds more effectively to pain, releasing a greater amount of soothing endorphins and enkephalins [source: Dye]. This estrogen-pain connection could explain why postmenopausal women with low estrogen suffer more from chronic painful conditions, such as fibromyalgia [source: Kritz].
Due to the differences between how male and female bodies process pain, some scientists have started taking a gender-specific approach to formulating painkillers.
Pink and Blue Painkillers?
Not only do men and women feel pain differently, but medication that relieves men's pain won't necessarily work as well -- or at all, in some cases -- in women. Until 1993, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulations excluded "women of childbearing age" from participating in clinical trial phases for new drugs, which meant that pharmaceutical companies often only tested on men [source: Toomey]. As a result, many painkiller formulations and dosages were developed based on the male body's pain response.
Morphine, one of the most commonly used painkillers, doesn't perform as effectively in both genders. For surgery patients undergoing general anesthesia, females require at least 30 percent more morphine than males [source: Toomey]. In addition, nalbuphine, which is often used to anesthetize women during childbirth, does little to mitigate pain in men [source: Economist].
Scientists attribute those gendered effects to variations in male and female brains. Both medications relieve pain by activating opioid receptors in the brain; opioid receptors counteract pain by blocking neurons from transmitting pain signals. Yet, morphine binds to a class of opioid receptors called mu receptors, and nalbuphine binds to kappa receptors. PET scans have shown, however, that mu receptors in healthy male and female brains activate through different pathways [source: Toomey]. Moreover, the male mu opioid system plays the starring role in pain relief, while the kappa system dominates in females.
Since drug testing was primarily focused on male pain responses in the past, the most popular painkillers were designed to stimulate mu opioids. As a result, chronic and severe pain in women has been harder to treat successfully. But now that scientists recognize that kappa receptor opioids better stifle pain in women, some are designing so-called "pink and blue painkillers" specifically tailored to males' and females' unique pain response systems [source: Economist]. If that becomes a medical reality, perhaps the gender pain gap will narrow in the future.
Related HowStuffWorks Articles
- Dye, Lee. "Studies Suggest Men Handle Pain Better." ABC News. (Jan. 30, 2010)http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/Story?id=97662&page=1
- "Gender and Pain." Society for Neuroscience. (Jan. 30, 2010)http://www.sfn.org/index.aspx?pagename=brainBriefings_Gender_and_Pain
- Hapidou, E.G. and DeCatanzaro, D. "Responsiveness to laboratory pain in women as a function of childbirth pain experience." Pain. February 1992. (Jan. 30, 2010)http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1589235
- Kritz, Francesca Lunzer. "Not Feeling Each Other's Pain." Washington Post. Dec. 19, 2006. (Jan. 30, 2010)http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/15/AR2006121501879.html
- "Illness and Pain." National Institutes of Health. April 1998. (Jan. 30, 2010)http://painconsortium.nih.gov/genderandpain/illness.htm
- "Pain, sex and drugs." Economist. July 21, 2005. (Jan. 30, 2010)
- Toomey, Matthew. "Gender Differences in Pain: Does X = Y?" AANA Journal. October 2008.
- University Of California - Los Angeles. "Gender Differences In Brain Response To Pain." ScienceDaily. (Nov. 5, 2003). Jan. 29, 2010http://www.sciencedaily.com /releases/2003/11/031105064626.htm
- "Women feel more pain than men, research shows." Medical News Today. July 4, 2005. (Jan. 30, 2010)http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/printerfriendlynews.php?newsid=26934