White Dwarfs Can Shred Planets to Pieces

By: Ian O'Neill, Ph.D.  | 

white dwarf star and disintegrating asteroid
This dead star is kept company by a disintegrating asteroid in this artist's concept. Stocktrek Images

When our sun runs out of hydrogen fuel in roughly 5 billion years, it will swell into a huge red giant star — violently shedding hot layers of plasma and cooking the inner planets to a crisp. All that will be left behind is an expanding bubble of cooling gas, creating a beautiful planetary nebula and a white dwarf in the middle, shining bright like a stellar diamond. Though we know this is the fate of our nearest star, what of the planets? What will happen to Earth?

Astronomers from the University of Warwick, U.K., took a stab at answering this question and have come up with a rudimentary "survival guide" for planets that find themselves in this grim scenario. While Earth's fate isn't necessarily clear, the study, published in the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, has revealed that when it comes to living with a white dwarf star, the tiniest worlds will reign.

Why is that? We know that many white dwarf star systems have quantities of dust surrounding them, and through spectroscopic measurements, dust has been found polluting these stars' atmospheres. The implication is clear: These star systems used to have rocky planets (plus asteroids and comets) in orbit, but, through extreme tidal interactions with their white dwarf, have been torn to shreds and ground to dust.


Radius of Destruction

So, why do planetary bodies get blended in white dwarf orbit? These exotic stellar objects contain nearly the entire mass of the dead star they came from in a blob of degenerate matter only the size of Earth. With this extreme density comes an incredibly powerful gravitational field and tidal forces. Stray too close to a white dwarf and a planet will experience a more powerful tidal force on the star-facing hemisphere than the hemisphere facing away. Depending on what that planet is made of, at a certain distance — known as the "destruction radius," demarked by an ominous dusty ring — the tidal shear through the planet will be too much, and it will be literally pulled apart.

To understand where the destruction radius is for a variety of planets of different sizes, the researchers carried out dynamic simulations of different planets in orbit around a sun-like star as it dies and passes through the red giant phase to a white dwarf. This violent phase of a star's life will disturb the orbit of the planets around it, dragging them to their dusty deaths or even flinging them to wider orbits.


Viscosity Is Everything

Interestingly, the researchers found that it isn't just the mass and composition of planets that affect how sensitive they are to the tidal shear, it's their viscosity, or the resistance they have to being deformed. They found that low-viscosity exoplanets — of a similar consistency to Saturn's moon Enceladus, which is approximately homogeneous — would be dragged to its doom if it resides within five-times its destruction radius from the white dwarf.

At the other extreme, a high-viscosity world could live comfortably if it orbits the white dwarf only twice its destruction orbit. Recently, astronomers discovered a dense "heavy metal" object around a white dwarf that is embedded inside a dusty disk. It's believed that this object, which isn't much bigger than a large asteroid, was the metal core of a larger planet that was destroyed by tidal shear, leaving its high-viscosity metallic core behind.

As the search for exoplanets (planets orbiting other stars) becomes more sophisticated, more worlds are going to be seen in white dwarf star systems, so the researchers hope that these simulations will act as a guide that will help us understand what these exoplanets are made of.


But What of Earth?

Although this dynamical simulation has provided some key insights to what it takes to avoid being dragged to a dusty death, it only simulates homogenous objects. When it comes to our planet, the problem becomes more complex.

"Our study, while sophisticated in several respects, only treats homogenous rocky planets that are consistent in their structure throughout," said lead author Dimitri Veras, in the University of Warwick's accompanying press release. "A multi-layer planet, like Earth, would be significantly more complicated to calculate but we are investigating the feasibility of doing so too."

In summary, it pays to be tiny and mighty, composed of heavy metals if you want to have a snug orbit around a white dwarf without being dragged to your death. As for Earth's fate, we'll have to wait and see — but in all honesty, you probably wouldn't want to be here when our red giant sun switches to "broil."

Learn more about our starry universe in Sara Gillingham's illustrated guide "Seeing Stars: A Complete Guide to the 88 Constellations." We at HowStuffWorks choose related titles based on books we think you'll like and the story you just read. Should you choose to buy one, we'll receive a portion of the sale.


Originally Published: May 22, 2019

White Dwarf FAQ

What is a white dwarf?
According to EarthSky, a white dwarf is the remains of a dead star.
What happens when white dwarfs die?
According to Space.com, when a white dwarf dies or no longer emits heat or light, it becomes a black dwarf.
Can a white dwarf go supernova?
The American Museum of Natural History states that a white dwarf will go supernova if it increases its mass enough to re-ignite nuclear fusion in its core.
Can a white dwarf destroy a planet?
If a planet with low viscosity strays too close to a white dwarf, the dwarf's incredibly powerful gravitational fields and tidal forces can tear the planet apart.
How hot is a white dwarf?
According to National Geographic, the temperature of a white dwarf can exceed 180,000 degrees Fahrenheit.
ScienceAstronomy TermsFloating PlanetScienceAstronomyHow Nomad Planets WorkScienceSpace ExplorationHow Planet Hunting WorksScienceThe Solar SystemWhy is Pluto no longer considered a planet?ScienceFuture SpaceHow Will We Colonize Other Planets?ScienceGeophysicsHow much does planet Earth weigh?ScienceThe Solar SystemWhy Did It Take So Long to 'Discover' Planet Nine?ScienceThe Solar SystemWhat's the Order of the Planets in the Solar System?ScienceThe Solar SystemDoes it rain on other planets?ScienceThe Solar SystemJupiter: Yokozuna of Gas Giants, Banisher of PlanetsScienceThe Solar SystemHow do planets form?ScienceStarsWhite Dwarfs Can Shred Planets to PiecesScienceThe Solar SystemWho Named Planet Earth?ScienceSpace ExplorationDoes a planet need continents to support life?ScienceThe Solar SystemIs Planet Nine Actually a Primordial Black Hole?ScienceSpace ExplorationHow many planets in our universe could support life?ScienceStarsCould a planet exist without a host star?ScienceThe Solar SystemWhy Are Planets Almost Spherical?ScienceThe Solar SystemNASA Announces New Solar System Packed With Seven PlanetsScienceThe Solar SystemPluto: Is It a Planet After All?ScienceThe Solar SystemHaumea, a Dwarf Planet in the Kuiper Belt, Has Its Own RingScienceSpace ExplorationNew NASA Satellite Is Hunting for Distant PlanetsScienceThe Solar SystemAncient Obliteration of Dwarf Planets May Have Created Saturn's RingsScienceThe Solar SystemIs Earth the Only Planet With Tectonic Plates?ScienceStarsHow do astronomers detect that a star has a planet orbiting it?ScienceSpace ExplorationCan we detect water on exoplanets?ScienceThe Solar SystemThe Truth Behind the Rogue Planet NibiruScienceThe Solar SystemUranus: The Planet on a Very Tilted AxisScienceThe Solar SystemPloonets: When Moons Become PlanetsScienceAstronomy TermsPlanetariumScienceSpace Exploration10 Remarkable ExoplanetsScienceSpace ExplorationClosest Exoplanet Yet Confirmed By European Southern ObservatoryScienceStarsSpotted: Early Planetary Formation Around a Binary Star SystemScienceStarsThis Is How We'll Detect Life on Distant ExoplanetsScienceSpace ExplorationNASA's Kepler Mission Adds 100 Alien Worlds to Exoplanet TallyScienceSpace ExplorationCan amateur astronomers spot exoplanets?ScienceFuture Space10 Best Ideas for Interplanetary CommunicationScienceSpace ExplorationLISA: Detecting Exoplanets Using Gravitational WavesScienceThe Solar SystemHow NASA Planetary Protection WorksScienceAstronomy TermsPlanetesimal Hypothesis