What's the Difference Between a Windmill and a Wind Turbine?

By: Trevor English  | 
At left, an old windmill stands against the blue sky in Consuegra, Spain, while wind turbines, at right, generate electricity at the San Gorgonio Pass Wind Farm near Palm Springs, California. Windmill: Pixabay; wind turbine: Robert Alexander/Getty Images

As the wind blows, so too do the vanes of windmills and wind turbines. These massive vaned machines have been around for over 1,000 years, with the first windmills appearing in Persia around 800 C.E.

These early windmills were used for exactly what their name implies — they were mills run by wind. Wind would spin the vanes, or blades, of the windmill, rotating a center shaft, which would then spin a grain mill, usually made of large, flat stones, to produce flour and other grain products. These windmills served another vital purpose too — pumping water to cities and houses. Rather than spinning a grain mill, the rotation of the windmill could be used to drive a pump.


While windmills have been around for ages, wind turbines have only been around since roughly 1888, when the first known wind turbine created for electricity production in the U.S. was built by inventor Charles Brush to create electricity for his mansion in Ohio. Wind turbines are used to generate electricity from the spinning of the blades, rather than simply converting that spinning energy into more mechanical work, such as turning a mill or pumping water.

"A wind turbine in the United States is around 280 feet (85 meters) tall, whereas the older windmill typically wouldn't top 80 feet (24 meters)," says James Herzing, engineer and award-winning host of the Unprofessional Engineering podcast, in an email interview. "The size of the sails or blades is another big difference. Windmills are traditionally measured by wheel diameter, and it isn't uncommon to see an 8-foot (2-meter) windmill, where 8 feet is measured across the blades. Wind turbines, on the other hand, can have a single blade well over 100 feet (30 meters)."


How Windmills Work

While windmills are some of the oldest and most vital machines to civilization and generally are used to pump water or mill grain, they do have some other functional differences to the much newer wind turbine technology.

The blades of a windmill are close to the ground and thus must harness air currents near the ground to spin. Since wind currents are generally less near Earth's surface than they are in higher atmospheres, windmills must have larger blades to catch as much wind as possible.


While windmills have been around since 800 C.E. or so, they really spread in popularity in the mid-1800s. Sparked by the Industrial Revolution in the decades following 1850, more than 6 million mechanical windmills were installed in the U.S. alone to power pumps and factories and serve other energy needs.

A windmill called 'The Stork' is still functional at the Duyvis cocoa and chocolate processing plant on the river Zaan, Netherlands.
Prisma by Dukas/Universal Images Group/Getty Images

This popularity was driven by the simplicity of windmills as mechanical energy generators. By simply putting a windmill with many vanes up, you could quickly garner access to a free mechanical energy source. Through the spinning of the blades, that rotational energy could be used to drive machines through gearing or used to push and pull water from the ground with simple water sucker-rod pumps.

As windmills were being popularized throughout modern industry, another invention was being developed and refined as well: the generator.

Rather than only being able to use a windmill when the wind was blowing, a generator would allow rotational energy to be stored by converting it into electricity. Thus, the development of wind turbines was the next step in perfecting wind energy harnessing devices.


How Wind Turbines Work

To catch stronger air currents, a wind turbine reaches hundreds of feet higher into the sky than a windmill does. It uses the same functional principles as a windmill – turning wind into rotational energy – but what it does next is different. Wind turbines have generators inside of them, usually directly connected to a spinning vane rod. By spinning the generator, an electric current is produced which can be used to charge batteries, feed into the grid, or run electronic devices directly. The best way to understand how this works is by considering a motor, but in reverse. An electric motor uses electricity to create motion, while a wind turbine uses motion to produce electricity.

More specifically, the blades of a wind turbine capture the kinetic energy – energy created by motion – of the wind and transform it into rotational energy. This rotational energy is then fed through a series of gears to increase the speed of a generator.


Wind turbine
Workers stand inside a giant wind turbine blade during construction near Mountainair, New Mexico.
Construction Photography/Avalon/Getty Images

These turbines generally start producing energy at wind speeds of 5 to 10 miles per hour (8 to 16 kilometers per hour) and shut off at high speeds near 60 mph (96 kph) so they don't malfunction or damage themselves, according to the American Wind Energy Association.

While wind turbines do produce electricity, they aren't technically as efficient as windmills. Wind turbines have a maximum efficiency of 59 percent, something known as the Betz limit. This is due to the inability to harness all of the wind's energy and inefficiencies in converting rotational energy into mechanical energy.


From Ancient Technology to Future Energy

Even with their inefficiencies, wind turbines are the wind-harnessing and electricity-creating way of the future. James says that he "see[s] wind turbines as an integral part of reducing, and eventually, eliminating our dependency on carbon fuels. A typical wind project repays its carbon footprint within six months, providing decades of zero-emission energy. In fact, some countries such as Scotland have already invested enough in wind energy that it can produce enough power to fuel two Scotlands!"

In 2018, wind generated roughly 5 percent of global electricity, making it the second largest renewable source, behind hydropower. From the windmill's first use as the mechanical backbone of early Persian and Chinese civilization, to today's massive wind turbines, the underlying technology is here to stay.


Frequently Asked Questions

How do the environmental impacts of windmills compare to wind turbines?
Windmills, traditionally used for mechanical tasks like grinding grain or pumping water, have minimal environmental impacts as they do not produce electricity or emit greenhouse gases. Wind turbines, on the other hand, are designed to generate electricity with a very low environmental footprint, significantly reducing carbon emissions compared to fossil fuel sources. However, they require more materials for construction and can affect local wildlife, particularly birds and bats.
Can wind turbines and windmills coexist in modern renewable energy strategies?
Yes, wind turbines and windmills can coexist in modern renewable energy strategies. Windmills can still be used for their historical applications in agriculture or water management, especially in remote or developing areas. Wind turbines complement these by providing clean electricity for local and national grids, contributing to a broader strategy of reducing reliance on fossil fuels and combating climate change. Each serves unique purposes within a sustainable and diversified energy portfolio.