Critics can spout a litany of reasons why a particular laureate falls short of the award's prestige. Often they argue lack of achievement. Sometimes they list uglier reasons. Honoring one person above others, especially a polarizing figure, naturally engenders conflict. This is the Nobel Peace Prize's second irony.
President Barack Obama belongs to the first category. Even ignoring the two wars he was embroiled in when selected, the timing meant that his nominations were submitted between two months before and two weeks after his election [source: CNN]. Some people wouldn't eat a banana that green.
Sometimes it's the achievement, not the laureate, that is too unripe. When Yasser Arafat, Shimon Peres and Yitzhak Rabin were honored in 1994, David Horovitz of the Financial Times said the honor was about "hopes of peace rather than peace itself" [source: BBC]. Events bore him out. Along similarly premature lines, North Vietnamese leader Le Duc Tho invaded South Vietnam just two years after sharing the award with Henry Kissinger in 1973.
Arafat and Kissinger also illustrate how laureates' checkered pasts incite controversy. A Nobel Committee member resigned over Arafat's selection, saying the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) leader was "too tainted by violence, terror and torture" [source: BBC]. When Kissinger received the award, musical satirist Tom Lehrer pronounced satire "officially dead" [sources: Frost, Thompson].
Although the prize committee chooses laureates based on singular accomplishments, the world tends to hold honorees to a higher standard. Kofi Annan's shared prize with the United Nations in 2001 rekindled criticism of their handling of Rwanda [source: Dallaire]. In 2004, Wangari Maathai became the first female African laureate, and received a thrashing for accusing scientists of creating HIV for biological warfare [source: ABC/AFP]. Rigoberta Menchú Tum received the prize in 1992 for casting light on the plight of Guatemalan indigenous peoples with her memoirs, which some argue were false [source: Horowitz].
There is always a group, internationally or at home, that considers a laureate a troublemaker -- or worse. Some would call Menachem Begin, Yasser Arafat, Henry Kissinger, Nelson Mandela, Shimon Perez and the fourteenth Dalai Lama terrorists, occupiers and/or war criminals. However, had the prize committee been influenced by such criticism, it might never have honored human rights activists like Albert Lutuli (1960), Martin Luther King Jr. (1964), Andrei Sakharov (1975), Adolfo Pérez Esquivel (1980), Aung San Suu Kyi (1991) or Liu Xiaobo (2010).
The fact that the committee did honor them is largely thanks to Carl von Ossietzky. During the run-up to World War II, many opposed honoring the anti-Nazi pacifist because it meant meddling in German internal affairs. However, many of the same people who balked at honoring Ossietzky supported Neville Chamberlain's nomination in 1938 for his appeasement of Germany, which left Czechoslovakia defenseless and opened the door to further Nazi aggression.
Now that's irony.
More Great Links
- ABC News/AFP. "Nobel Peace Laureate Claims HIV Deliberately Created." Oct. 9, 2004. (March 18, 2011)http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200410/s1216687.htm
- BBC. "On This Date: 14 October 1994: Israelis and Arafat Share Peace Prize." (March 21, 2011) http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/october/14/newsid_3694000/3694744.stm
- Beyer, Lisa, Jamil Hamad, Robert Slater and Ann M. Simmons. "Murderers of Peace." Time Magazine. Oct. 24, 1994. (March 19, 2011)http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,981669-1,00.html
- CNN. "Obama: Nobel Peace Prize is 'Call to Action.'" Oct. 9, 2009. (March 2, 2011)http://articles.cnn.com/2009-10-09/world/nobel.peace.prize_1_norwegian-nobel-committee-international-diplomacy-and-cooperation-nuclear-weapons?_s=PM:WORLD
- Dallaire, Roméo and Samantha Power. "Shake Hands with the Devil: The Failure of Humanity in Rwanda." Da Capo Press. Dec. 21, 2004.
- Encyclopaedia Britannica Online. "Nobel Prizes." (March 18, 2011)http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/416856/Nobel-Prize/93434/The-prizes
- Frost, Caroline. "Henry Kissinger: Profile." BBC4. June 2005. (March 20, 2011)http://www.bbc.co.uk/bbcfour/documentaries/features/feature_kissinger_profile.shtml
- Horowitz, David. "Right On!" Salon. Jan. 11, 1999.
- Lemmel, Birgitta. "Alfred Nobel--St. Petersburg, 1842-1863." (March 20, 2011)http://nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/biographical/articles/russia/index.html
- Parker, Sybil. "Progressive Powder." Dictionary of Scientific and Technical Terms. McGraw-Hill. 2003.
- Ringertz, Nils. "Alfred Nobel--His Life and Work." (March 19, 2011)http://nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/biographical/articles/life-work/index.html
- Tagil, Sven. "Alfred Nobel's Thoughts about War and Peace." Nov. 20, 1998. (March 21, 2011)http://nobelprize.org/alfred_nobel/biographical/articles/tagil/
- Thompson, Stephen. "Interview: Tom Lehrer." AV Club. May 24, 2000. (March 20, 2011)http://www.avclub.com/articles/tom-lehrer,13660/
- Tønnesson, Øyvind. "Controversies and Criticisms." June 29, 2000. (March 18, 2011)http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/peace/articles/controversies/