Rage Against the Machine: Religious Anger and Political Anger
Discussing religion and politics may provide many anger triggers for an opinionated person. But in addition to providing the potential for heated discussion, anger, religion and politics often intersect in interesting ways.
Public anger is anger that is collectively directed toward the institutions in power. We express this kind of anger when we vote, based on what we think is wrong with the country and what needs to be done about it. Without public anger exploding over the course of U.S. history, we might still have slaves, and white men would be the only ones allowed to vote. Perhaps we wouldn't even be talking about the United States -- we'd still be colonies. Anger can be a powerful force for changing things that madden us about society.
But what of God's anger with society? In 2006, Ray Nagin, the mayor of New Orleans, garnered attention for saying that Hurricane Katrina occurred because "God is mad at America" and black communities [source: Martel]. That's but one example from history of people grappling with earthly events as signs of God's wrath; from the Black Death to the attacks of Sept. 11, many have been concerned about whether God is expressing anger.
People of all religious faiths have also struggled with scriptural evidence of whether God or other religious deities want us to express anger. Anger is roundly criticized in Buddhist texts, and the Dalai Lama once said that even in reacting to disturbing news in Tibet, he rarely feels anger, which can "poison the mind and embitter the heart" [source: Vernezze]. Sometimes the evidence can be more conflicting, with Christians trying to reconcile Jesus' anger in the temple with his command to turn the other cheek.
Some see the former as a "righteous anger," which can become troublesome when we adopt the excuse for ourselves. Much violence has been committed in God's name, and suicide bombings and wars are tragic examples of two viewpoints, both justified to believers, clashing. In 2007, a study of almost 500 college students examined the effect of violence in Scripture. Half of the students were from Brigham Young University, a religious university associated with the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. The other half were from Vrije Universiteit in Amsterdam. Of the Dutch students, 50 percent said they believed in God, and 27 percent believed in the Bible, while 99 percent of the Brigham Young students believed in God and the Bible [source: Bushman et al.].
The groups were asked to read an obscure biblical passage that told of a woman's brutal killing and her husband's revenge, which involved killing everyone in several cities. Half the participants were told that the story was biblical, while the other half was told that the story was found on an ancient scroll. Half of both groups were provided an additional sentence that indicated that God commanded the husband's violence.
The groups were then tested for aggression, using a common laboratory exercise for measuring the behavior. The study found that religious students acted more aggressively when told that the violence was in the Bible. But both religious and nonreligious students were more aggressive when told that the violence was sanctioned by God, although nonreligious students were less affected than religious ones [source: Bushman et al.].
This study indicates that scriptural violence has an effect on believers, but the study's authors note that this was one violent episode taken out of context. If religious extremists were to focus on such passages, they might be angrier, but within the context of an entire scriptural work, believers find many examples of how to deal with anger more peacefully.
Related HowStuffWorks Articles
More Great Links
- Andrews, Linda Wasmer. "When It's Time for Anger Management." HR Magazine. June 2005.
- Angier, Natalie. "If Anger Ruins Your Day, It Can Shrink Your Life." New York Times. Dec. 13, 1990. (June 2, 2008)http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C0CE7D61731F930A25751C1A966958260&scp=1&sq=if+anger+ruins+your+day&st=nyt
- Bushman, Brad J., Robert D. Ridge, Enny Das, Colin W. Key and Gregory L. Busath. "When God Sanctions Killing: Effects of Scriptural Violence on Aggression." Psychological Science. 2007. (June 10, 2008) http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bbushman/BRDKB07.pdf
- Carey, Benedict. "Anger Management May Not Help at All." New York Times. Nov. 24, 2004. (June 2, 2008) http://www.nytimes.com/2004/11/24/health/24anger.html?_r=1&oref=slogin
- Carpenter, Sandra and Amy G. Halberstadt. "Mothers' Reports of Events Causing Anger Differ Across Family Relationships." Social Development. 2000.
- "Controlling Anger -- Before It Controls You." American Psychological Association. (June 3, 2008) http://www.apa.org/topics/controlanger.html
- Cromie, William J. "Probing inappropriate rage." Harvard News Office. Aug. 6, 2004. (June 2, 2008)http://www.hno.harvard.edu/gazette/2004/08.26/01-anger.html
- Deffenbacher, Jerry L. "Anger-Management Programs: Issues and Suggestions." Behavioral Health Management. November/December 2004.
- Diong, Siew Mann, George D. Bishop, Hwee Chong Enkelmann, Eddie M.W. Tong, Yong Peng Why, Jansen C.H. Ang, and Majeed Khader. "Anger, stress, coping, social support and health: Modeling the relationships." Psychology and Health. August 2005.
- Ellison, Katherine. "Mastering Your Own Mind." Psychology Today. September/October 2006.
- Finlay, Liza. "The Art of the Hissy Fit." Flare. April 2008.
- Kam, Katherine. "Rein in the Rage: Anger and Heart Disease." WebMD. (June 2, 2008) http://www.webmd.com/heart-disease/features/rein-in-rage-anger-heart-disease
- Katz, Jon. "Do Dogs Think?" Slate. Oct. 6, 2005. (June 2, 2008)http://www.slate.com/id/2127419/
- Lench, Heather C. "Anger Management: Diagnostic Differences and Treatment Implications." Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology. 2004.
- Linden, Wolfgang, Deborah Leung, Anuradha Chawla, Carmen Stossel, Thomas Rutledge, and Sheryl A. Tanco. "Social Determinants of Experienced Anger." Journal of Behavioral Medicine. 1997.
- Martel, Brett. "Storms Payback From God, Nagin Says." Washington Post. Jan 17. 2006. (June 11, 2008)http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/content/article/2006/01/16/ AR2006011600925.html
- McCarthy, Jenna. "Anger Management." Real Simple. June 2008.
- Painuly, Nitesh, Pratap Sharan and Surendra K. Mattoo. "Relationship of anger and anger attacks with depression: A brief review." European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience. Nov. 12, 2004.
- Peacock, Judith. "Anger Management." LifeMatters Books. 2000.
- Sahagun, Louis and Jocelyn Y. Stewart. "Traditional View of an Angry God Has Softened." Los Angeles Times. Jan. 28, 2006.
- Siever, Larry J. "Neurobiology of Aggression and Violence." The American Journal of Psychiatry." April 2008.
- "Studies' message to women: keep your cool." Women's Health Weekly. April 17, 2008.
- Tangley, Laura. "Animal Emotions." U.S. News & World Report. Oct. 30, 2000.
- Tavris, Carol. "Anger: The Misunderstood Emotion." Simon & Schuster. 1982.
- Thomas, Sandra P. "Anger: The Mismanaged Emotion." Dermatology Nursing. August 2003.
- Thomas, Sandra P., Carol Smucker and Patricia Droppleman. "It hurts most around the heart: a phenomenological exploration of women's anger." Journal of Advanced Nursing. 1998.
- Vernezze, Peter J. "Moderation or the Middle Way: Two Approaches to Anger." Philosophy East and West. January 2008.
- Weber, Hannelore. "Explorations in the Social Construction of Anger." Motivation and Emotion. June 2004.